v3 show comments by default gone

5.81K viewsGeneral
1

Hi,

I see, that “show comments by default” option from the admin panel is gone. Is there any chance that this feature will return in the near future? I was really using it.

0

Hi all!

Sorry for adding an answer here but I thought it would be better to keep things related to the new comment system in the same place. I just realized there is an UX issue with the new system. When you get a notification email about a new comment, the link doesn’t take you to that specific comment any more (with url/#comment-2012 for example). With a lot of answers and comments, it’s impossible to find the recently added comment in the thread…

Hope this info will be useful. 😉

commented on answer

Hello Fred,
This is a bug. Thanks for reporting

1

There are few reasons behind that:

  1. Takes too much space when there are lots of comments.
  2. Slow page loading.

So, we decided to keep it hidden by default.

commented on answer

Is it possible to show them by a filter? Can you post some advice on how to show comments by default? I would like to do that.

I’d like to see this feature coming back to. Loading a handful of ‘teaser’ comments asynchronously and a “more” button would be perfect.

I completely agree with ptrcklpzg: load the first comments and a “more” button. It would help for posts with many comments and would be perfect for those with just a few ones. 😀

I completely agree with ptrcklpzg too!

Nonetheless there should be a option to show last 2-3 or so, and button / link to show them all, with ajaxed pagination if there is to much. That way there is just better UX overall.